Salem Cemetery Lot No. 06: Edward Arnold, Owner

Lot No. 6 contains six graves, five marked and one unmarked. Family patriarch David Arnold is buried at the north end of the lot. His wife, Alpha (Seaward) Arnold lies in an unmarked grave south of his. To the south of Alpha are their son and daughter-in-law, Edward and Sophia (Barnhart) Arnold; Kitty, an infant daughter of Edward and Sophia; and the unnamed infant daughter (and only child) of Mandaville and Doneta (Holmes) Arnold who are buried in the Russell Cemetery.

DAVID ARNOLD'S tombstone is among the most interesting at Salem, combining as it does a marble base topped by a polished granite column. When this photo was taken, the whole confection was topped with a small marble urn. Sadly, that has fallen off (it was secured by an iron rod that rusted away).

I discovered the damage as the result of one of those odd experiences that sometimes happen in cemeteries. Stopping by late one afternoon a couple of years ago now, I got out of the truck and it seemed immediately as if something were wrong --- even a little creepy. I couldn't place it, but started scanning the cemetery. After looking around for a while, it dawned on me that the Arnold tombstone didn't look the way it should, walked over and found the urn alongside instead of on top. I turned it over to one of David's descendants, Ilene Church of Chariton, so perhaps it's still available should someone want to attempt to reunite urn and column. In any case, the inscription on the north face of the stone reads:

DAVID ARNOLD
BORN
Feb. 18, 1791
In Herkimer Co., N.Y.
DIED
Apr. 27, 1880
AGED
89y, 1 Mo, 5 Ds

David does not have a published obituary. Only the following death notice, published in The Chariton Patriot of 5 May 1880, can be found:

Died, Arnold: At the residence of his son, Ed Arnold, in Benton Township, on April 27th, Mr. David Arnold, age 89 years.

The closest I've come to a published biography is the following exerpt from the biographical account of his son, Edward, published on pp. 251-253 of "A Memorial and Biographical Record of Iowa" (Chicago: Lewis Publishing Co., 1896). This account is filled with errors, so can only be trusted so far.

David Arnold was a native of Herkimer county, New York, of blue Yankee blood, and was a soldier in the war of 1812. He was married in New York to Miss Alpha Seward (actually Seaward), a relative of the Hon. William H. Seward, and also a native of the Empire State. After their marriage they moved to Guernsey county, Ohio, where they maintained their home for forty years, removing thence to Marion county, Iowa. He died in Marion county, on his farm, at the advanced age of eighty-five years (actually he didn't; he died at the home of Edward Arnold in Benton Township, Lucas County, and was 89). He had been a miller in Ohio, but the latter part of his life was devoted to agricultural pursuits. In his political views he was first a Whig and later a Republican. His wife died in Chariton, Iowa, at the age of eighty-six (actually 95) years, a true Christian and a devoted member of the Baptist Church. They had eight children,viz.: Lucy Parker, Omaha, Nebraska; Samuel, Perry county, Ohio; Lovina, Rosenburg, Oregon; David, Winterset, Iowa; Stephen, Chariton, Iowa; Edward, whose name initiates this article; Mary Bonebreak, Rosenburg, Oregon; and Phoebe Combstock, deceased, formerly of Burlington, Iowa.

+++

Although her grave is unmarked, David Arnold's wife, ALPHA SEAWARD ARNOLD, is buried just south of the stone that marks his grave. If her children had commissioned an inscription for her on the stone, it might read:

ALPHA ARNOLD
Wife of David Arnold
Born: Feb. 18, 1796, in Ostego County, N.Y.
Died: Oct. 5, 1891, at Chariton, Iowa

If an obituary for Alpha Arnold was published, it was in an edition of a Chariton newspaper that no longer is extant. The following death notice was published in The Chariton Herald-Patriot on 8 October 1891:

DIED: At the home of her son, S.S. Arnold, in Chariton, Ia., Monday morning Oct. 5, 1891, Mrs. Alpha Arnold, at the age of 95 years.The funeral was conducted at Mr. Arnold's Tuesday Oct. 6, at 1 o'clock, the sermon being preached by Rev. D. Austin from a text selected by Mrs. Arnold several months ago, and the remains laid to rest in the Salem cemetery south-east of town.

This photo of Alpha (seated at left) and two of her sisters was taken during a reunion in Chariton during the fall of 1881, when Alpha was 85. Mary (Seaward) Tripp/Flint (1799-1895; of Peoria, Ill.) is steated at right; and Sibbel (Seaward) McNall (1811-1891, of New York) is standing.

+++

The graves of Edward and Sophia Arnold are marked by a large family stone with no inscription other than the surname "Arnold" that is flanked by small headstones marking the individual graves, Edward to the north and Sophia to the south.

EDWARD
ARNOLD
Aug. 6, 1832
Feb. 2, 1906
Gone but not forgotten

OBITUARIES: EDWARD ARNOLD

The many friends throughout the county of Edward Arnold of Benton township will greatly regret to learn of his death, which occurred at his home on Friday morning, February 2, 1906, at 1:30 o'clock, after an illness of several weeks with dropsy and heart trouble. Largely attended funeral services, conducted by Rev. Blackburn, were held at the Salem church on Sunday morning at eleven o'clock after which interment took place in the Salem cemetery.

Edward Arnold was born in Concord, Muskingum county, Ohio, on August 6, 1832. In the spring of 1855 he came to Iowa, locating in Marion county, near Newbern. He enlisted in the army in August, 1862, and served until the close of the war when he received an honorable discharge. He was a member of Company G, 48th Iowa Infantry. In the spring of 1856 he was married at Knoxville to Sophia Barnhart, who survives him. They were the parents of eight children, seven of whom are living. They are Mandeville and James, Mrs. Will Holmes and Mrs. Greer Redlingshafer of Benton township, Morris of Humeston, Mrs. Hattie Redlingshafer of Des Moines and Mrs. Dillie Johnson of Kirksville, Mo. One daughter, Mrs. Geo. Smith, died a few years ago. In 1872 Mr. Arnold and family moved to Benton township, this county, and that place has since been their home. Deceased was one of our most progressive and thrifty farmers and was highly regarded by all who knew him. He was honest and upright in all his dealings and possessed a kind and pleasant disposition. These characteristics, coupled with his generous nature and willing hand in time of trouble won him innumerable friends who mourn his death sincerely, and who extend heartfelt sympathy to the bereaved relatives. Mr. Arnold is also survived by two brothers and three sisters, S.S. Arnold of this city, David of Des Moines, Mrs. Lucy Parker of Omaha, Neb., Mrs. Lavina Hunter and Mrs. Mary Bonebrake of Lewisburg, Oregon. (The Chariton Leader, Feb. 8, 1906)

THE GRIM REAPER'S HARVEST: EDWARD ARNOLD

Edward Arnold, one of the most highly respected residents of Lucas county, died at his home in Benton township last Friday, Feb. 2, 1906, from stomach trouble, resulting in heart failure. He suffered a hemorrhage of the brain the day previous. Funeral services were held from the Salem church Sunday at 11 o'clock a.m., conducted by Rev. W.S. Blackburn, and interment made in the Salem cemetery.

Deceased was born near New Concord, Ohio, Aug. 6, 1832. He was raised on a farm in Ohio and much of his youth was spent working in his father's mill. His education was received during the winter months in one of the log school houses of those early days. In 1855 he came overland with a team and wagon, settling in Dallas township, Marion county, and engaged in farming. April 17, 1856, he was married to Miss Sophia
Barnhart, and to this union ten children were born, seven of whom are living.

When the civil war broke out he enlisted Aug. 15, 1862, in Company G, Fortieth Iowa Infantry, for a term of three years and was a participant in a number of engagements. He was honorably discharged at Davenport in August, 1865, coming out of the service as Quartermaster Sergeant.

In 1872 Mr. Arnold moved to Lucas county and settled in Liberty township, where he resided until 1875, when he removed to his late home in Benton township. He possessed a generous and jovial nature and was held in high esteem by his fellow citizens. His political views were in harmony with the principles advocated by the republican party, in which for years he was an active and effective worker.

The surviving children are: Mrs. Phoebe Holmes, Mrs. Augusta Redlingshafer, Mandaville and James, Benton township; Mrs. Della Anderson, Kirksville, Mo.; Mrs. Hattie Redlingshafer, Des Moines, Ia.; and Morris, of Garden Grove. All were with him during his illness. The bereaved wife and children request us to express their heartfelt thanks to the many kind friends and neighbors who extended sympathy and assistance in their hour of sorrow. (Undated clipping, possibly The Chariton Patriot)

+++


SOPHIA
ARNOLD
Jan. 2, 1838
Dec. 6, 1918

OBITUARY: SOPHIA ARNOLD

Sophia Arnold was born in Clearfield county, Pennsylvania, January 2, 1837, and died at the home of her daughter, Mrs. Augusta Redlingshafer, in Benton township, on Dec. 6, 1918. Her age was 81 years, 11 months and 4 days. She was the wife of Edward Arnold, who preceded her in death 12 years ago.

She had been a resident of Lucas county as follows: In Benton township 31 years; after the death of her husband she moved to Chariton, until she decided to make her home with her children until death. She was the mother of ten children, four of whom are deceased. Mortimer and Kitty died in infancy. Mrs. Estella Smith twenty years ago and Mrs. Phoeba May Holmes, whose untimely death six years ago many will remember. Those now living are Mandeville, who resides near the old home place; Morris, of Garden Grove; Mrs. Hattie Redlingshafer, of Des Moines; Mrs. Augusta Redlingshafer, of Benton township; and Mrs. Della Anderson and James Walter, of Wanamaker, South Dakota, who was not able to attend his mother's funeral. He was called home but was able to visit her shortly before she passed away to her great comfort. She also leaves 32 grandchildren and 38 great-grandchildren. She was converted in youth and lived a consistent christian life, being loved and respected by all her neighbors and very many friends. She was of a family of fourteen children, only one of whom survives her, Mrs. Matilda Poush, of Davis City, who is in feeble health.

The funeral services were conducted by Rev. E.W. Curtis at the Salem church on Saturday, Dec. 7, and the interment was in the cemetery near. {Chariton Herald Patriot, Dec. 12, 1918)

+++


Infant Dau. of
M & D Arnold
Aug. 4, 1881

KITTY
Feb 25, 1875
Nov. 3, 1878

Salem Cemetery Lot No. 07: W.H. Holmes (Simon Scott)

Lot No. 7 was sold originally to Simon Scott, son of Aaron Scott, whose lot (No. 20) is immediately south. There is no indication that the Simon Scotts, who are buried in the Russell Cemetery, ever used it, however. The five marked graves belong to members of the family of William and Pheoba (Arnold) Holmes. These readings are from south to north.

The graves of William H. and Pheoby M. Holms are marked jointly by a substantial red granite stone with graceful curves that contains inscriptions for both. A headstone engraved "MOTHER" north of the principal stone marks Pheoby's grave; a headstone engraved "FATHER" south of principal stone marks William's grave. Note that the name is spelled "Pheoby" on the tombstone, although all print references spell it the traditional way, "Phoebe."

HOLMES
W.H. HOLMES
1857-1948

OBITUARY: WILLIAM H. HOLMES

William Hamilton Holmes, son of Daniel and Mary Holmes, was born in Lucas County, Iowa, January 1, 1857, and departed this life at his home in Chariton, March 18, 1948, at the age of 91 years, 3 months and 18 days.

On September 30, 1879, he was married to Phoebe Arnold, who died June 22, 1912. To this union seven children were born all of whom are living.

He was married October 12, 1915, to Alice Dorsey, who passed away February 20, 1947.

Mr. Holmes was the sixth child in a family of eight children. Two sisters remaining to mourn his passing.

He was a pioneer farmer of Benton township, living on the same farm his father purchased from the government in 1854, until 1915 when he moved to Chariton. He was also a long time member of the I.O.O.F. lodge of Chariton.

He leaves to mourn his passing, three sons George and Glen Holmes of Harlingen, Texas, and Edward of Confidence, and four daughters, Jennie Querry and LaBernia Campbell of Chariton; Vivian Cain, of Park City, Monleau, Canada (sic; only three listed). Other survivors include 39 grandchildren, 61 great grandchildren and seven great great grandchildren, two sisters, Doneta Arnold of Chariton and Ida McKinley, of Avard, Okla., and sister-in-law, Melessie J. Holmes, of Russell and a host of nephews and nieces.

Funeral services were held Sunday, March 21, at 2 o'clock at the Dunshee funeral home. The Rev. A.E. Beals officiated. Burial was made at Salem Cemetery. (Undated clipping, Russell Union Tribune, Lucas County Genealogical Society collection)

This probably is the wedding picture of William H. and Pheobe May (Arnold) Holmes, taken during the fall of 1879.

HOLMES
PHEOBY M., His Wife
1862-1912
OBITUARY: MRS. WM. HOLMES

The funeral services of Mrs. Wm. Holmes, who died from injuries received in a runaway accident on Wednesday, July 27, were held on Friday afternoon at 2:30 o'clock, at Salem church, conducted by Rev. Young, of the Evangelical church, of Russell, after which the remains were laid to rest in Salem cemetery. The last sad rites were attended by a large concourse of sorrowing relatives and friends, and the floral tributes were profuse and beautiful, bearing testimony to the high regard in which deceased was held.

Phoebe May Arnold, daughter of Edward and Sophia Arnold, was born Feb. 22, 1862, in Marion county, Iowa, and died at her home in Benton township, Lucas county, on June 26, 1912 aged 50 years, 4 months and 4 days. She was one of a family of ten children, six of whom survive her to mourn their loss, Mandville Arnold, of Benton township, Morris, of near Humeston, James, of South Dakota, Mrs. Hattie Redlingshafer of Des Moines, Mrs. Della Anderson and Mrs. Augusta Redlingshafer of Benton township. Estella Smith died some years ago and two others died in infancy.

Phoebe May Arnold and Wm. H. Holmes were united in marriage Sept. 20, 1878 (1879 according to Lucas County marriage records). To this union were born seven children, Edward, who lives just south of the home place, Mrs. Jennie Querry and Mrs. La Bernice Campbell, who reside near Lucas and George, Vivian, Mary and Glen who are still at home with their father.

"While on her way to Chariton in company with her son George, the team became frightened, throwing them out of the buggy, from which she received serious injuries which proved fatal a few hours later. Her death came very unexpectedly and was a terrible shock to the family and also to the community. Her sufferings were intense and when the end came she had on her face that look of joy which speaks of the land where sufferings are no more. In sickness she was ever ready to lend a helping hand to those in need and was of a very cheery disposition and was loved by all her neighbors. She was a kind mother, an affectionate sister, a good wife and a kind neighbor.

"She leaves an aged mother, Mrs. Ed Arnold, of this city, three sisters, three brothers, a husband and seven children who will have the sympathy of the entire community in their overwhelming grief." (Undated clipping, Lucas County Genealogical Society collection)

+++

Immediately to the north of the graves of William H. and Pheoby Holmes is another large red granite family stone inscribed only "Holmes." To its north is a smaller stone marking the grave of MAYME BLANCHE (FOSTER) HOLMES, wife of George Holmes, who probably intended to be buried here as well but moved to Texas. George was a son of William H. and Pheoby.

MAYME BLANCHE
HOLMES
1892-1922

OBITUARY: MRS. GEO. A. HOLMES

Mamie (sic) Blanche, daughter of Charles E. and Clara Foster, was born in Lucas county, Iowa, where her entire life has been spent, on September 14, 1892, and departed this life at the home of her parents in Chariton at 3 a.m. on December 25, 1922, at the age of 30 years, 3 months and 11 days. She had not been in the best of health during the summer but her condition had not been considered serious. Two weeks ago she came into Chariton to be with her mother and to receive medical care. Her trouble did not seem to yield to the treatment, as she kept growing gradually worse until at last an operation was decided upon, to which she submitted on Sunday morning at 10:30 o'clock. She regained consciousness after this and conversed with different members of the family, seemingly most hopeful though she suffered intense pain at intervals. At 10:30 p.m. she passed into a stupor, from which she never rallied, the spirit taking its flight at 3 o'clock Christmas morning.

"On April 22, 1912, at Red Oak, Iowa, she was married to George Albert Holmes, who survives her, there being no children born to this union. She also leaves her parents, three brothers and three sisters, Mrs. Bessie Kenney, of Purdy, Iowa; Mrs. Ruth Grant and Fern Foster of Des Moines; Bryan, of Valley Junction; Don, a student at Des Moines University; and Emmet, of the home, besides numerous other relatives and friends.

"The deceased united with the M.E. church in early girlhood and has always Maintained her affiliation with that church. She was of a happy disposition, invariably cheerful herself and constantly intent upon imparting cheer to others. She was united in her devotion to her husband and home and always allowed her interest to reach out in loving helpfulness to her mother and brothers and sisters. Though her years of usefulness seemshort she has left a place in the hearts and lives of her loved ones that can never be filled and the memory of her kindly spirit will ever leave its imprint upon them.

Funeral services, conducted by the pastor, Rev. Frank Bean, were held at the M.E. church on Wednesday afternoon at two o'clock, after which the remains were laid to rest in the Salem cemetery. The sympathy of the entire community is extended to the bereaved ones. (The Chariton Herald-Patriot, 28 December 1922)

Note: Lucas County death records show that Mayme died of "general peritonitis," suggesting that appendicitis may have been the root cause.

+++

The northernmost graves on the lot are those of WILLIAM J. AND LABURNA A. CAMPBELL, marked by a single stone. Laburna was a daughter of William H. and Pheoba Holmes.

CAMPBELL
WILLIAM J. (south inscription)
1877-1962
LABURNA A. (North inscription)
1885-1971

OBITUARY: WILLIAM JOHN "JACK" CAMPBELL

William John (Jack) Campbell, son of John and Ellen Campbell, was born Aug. 21, 1877, at Cork County, Ireland, and departed this life Sunday, Jan. 4, 1962, at the age of 84 years, four months and 23 days.

He spent his early childhood at Pontiac, Ill., later coming to Iowa where he had since resided, making his living as a farmer in or near Lucas county.

He was united in marriage to Laburnia A. Holmes at Osceola, Dec. 21, 1905.

He is survived by his wife; three daughters: Vivian Kent of Lucas, Ellen Dixon of Indianola, Berniece Dennison of Knoxville; and two sons: William J. of Indianola and Daryle H. of Concord, Calif.: sons-in-law Bill Dennison, Bob Dixon and Rex Miner; daughters-in-law Evelyn and Josephine. Also surviving are two sisters, Ellen Bohm of Pontiac, Ill., and Jessie Webb of Ottumwa; a brother-in-law, Art Mote of Ottumwa; 14 grandchildren, seven great-grandchildren, nieces and nephews, and other relatives and friends.

His parents, a daughter, Frankie J. Miner, two brothers, Robert and Frank, a sister, Ada Mote, a son-in-law, Raymond Kent, and a grandson, Dean Kent, preceded him in death.

During his illness he bore his suffering always with patience and kindness. He was a devoted husband, a loving father, a much loved grandfather and a helpful neighbor.

"A precious one is gone, A voice we loved is still, A place is vacant in our home, That never can be filled." (The Chariton Leader, 23 January 1962)

OBITUARY: LABURNA A. (HOLMES) CAMPBELL

Laburna A. (Holmes) Campbell, daughter of William H. and Pheoba Holmes, was born March 14, 1885 and departed this life Wednesday, June 9, 1971 at the age of 86 years, 2 months, and 25 days. She had been in poor health for the last six months.

Most of her life was spent in the Lucas County area.

She was united in marriage to William J. Campbell at Osceola, December 21, 1905. To this union were born six children, Vivian Kent of Lucas, Bernice Dennison of Knoxville, William J. Campbell of Indianola, Daryle Campbell of San Pablo, Calif., and two daughters who are deceased, Ellen Dixon and Frankie Miner.

In addition to her children who survived, she is also survivedby a brother, Edward Holmes of Seymour, and two sisters, Vivian Cain of Laurel, Mont., and Mary Rumble of Moose Jaw,Sask., Canada.

Preceeding her in death were her husband, parents, a son-in-law, Dean Kent, two brothers, George and Glenn Holmes, and a sister, Jennie Querrey.

She will be greatly missed by her family, 15 grandchildren, 20 great-grandchildren, many nieces and nephews and many friends, both old and young, because to know her was to love her.

"A precious one is gone, A voice we loved is stilled, A place is vacant in our home, That never can be filled.

"Funeral services were conducted by the Rev. William J. Travis at 1:00 p.m., Saturday, June 12, 1971, at the Beardsley-Fielding Funeral Home. Interment was in the Salem Cemetery. (Undated clipping, Lucas County Genealogical Society collection)

BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH: WILLIAM H. HOLMES
"A Memorial and Biographical Record of Iowa"

A Memorial and Biographical Record of Iowa," published during 1896 by the Lewis Publishing Co. of Chicago, is one of the great genealogical resources of Lucas County, providing your ancestor had enough cash on hand when the salesman called to purchase a place in it for his or her biography. The biographies it include generally are long and extremely detailed, but subject to the usual cautions: There's nothing objective about them, the authors' memories were sometimes faulty and typographical errors sometimes occurred in the publication process.

The William H. Holmes biography, which appears on pages 155 and 156, is a good example of how much genealogical information can be crammed into a limited space.

WILLIAM H. HOLMES, as a native of Lucas county, Iowa, and as one of its representative farmers and esteemed citizens, is entitled to specific recognition
in this work, which aims impartially to portray the lives of the men and women who settled up this part of Iowa and of those who are to-day among its leading people.

William H. Holmes first saw the light of day in Benton township, Lucas county, Iowa, January 1, 1857, his parents being Daniel and Mary (Hamilton) Holmes, pioneers of Iowa, the former having died many years ago and the latter still residing at the old home place. Daniel Holmes was born in Jackson county, Indiana, February 3, 1814, and died February 1, 1864, in Iowa, his last resting place being in the Waynick cemetery, where a monument has been erected to his memory (Waynick Cemetery, also known sometimes as Holmes Cemetery, is located in Section 1 of Warren Township, Lucas County, about three-quarters of a mile due west of Benton Township's northwest corner). He was one of a family of eleven children, six sons and five daughters, and only one of that number is now living - Gresham of Benton township, Lucas County. Grandfather Fergus Holmes was a native of North Carolina, the great-grandfather Holmes having emigrated from his native land,the Emerald Isle, to North Carolina, at an early period in the history of thiscountry, and some years later moving to Indiana, where he died. Fergus Holmes was a farmer and passed his life in Indiana. The father of our subject, Daniel Holmes, was married in Jackson county, Indiana, December 2, 1841, to Miss Mary Hamilton, the ceremony being performed by her brother, Esquire Hamilton, and at her father's residence, which was about eighteen miles from where the Holmes family lived. Ten years after their marriage they removed from Indiana to Illinois and settled in Warren county, and about the middle of September, 1854, came to Iowa. This journey from Illinois to Benton township, Lucas county, Iowa, consumed about five days, and was made with two wagons, in which they brought their household goods and in which the family rode, their children numbering five. Theyalso brought along five head of cattle. Arrived here, Mr. Holmes purchased a tract of land from the Government and settled on it. Subsequently he rented a farm of Mr. Samuel Ragsdale, who resided just across the river from where William Holmes now lives. In the public affairs of this pioneer settlement he took an active and commendable part, serving on the Board of Supervisors and also as School Director. Politically, he was first a Whig and from the organization of the Republican party was one of its supporters.

Daniel Holmes and his wife were the parents of eight children, three sons and five daughters, as follows: Oscar F., born February 10, 1843, was a Union soldier and died of disease at the battle of Shiloh, his remains being interred in the national cemetery at that place; Deliah H., born March 10, 1845, died July 4, 1864; Leonidas, born May 13, 1848, resides in Hutchinson, Kansas; Eradna L., born May 23, 1851, is the wife of John Pierce, a farmer of Washington township, Lucas county; Sarah A., born December 13, 1853, is the wife of George Parsons, Washington township, this county; William H., born January 1, 1857, was the first of the family born in Iowa; Doneta A. (no birth date given), wife of M. Arnold, a farmer in Benton township; and Ida N., born December 23, 1862, is the wife of Franklin McKinley. The venerable mother of this family is still living and in the enjoyment of comparatively good health,her home being at the old farmstead. Besides the children above named, she has fifteen grandchildren. Of her people, the Hamiltons, we further record that they are Irish. Her father, James Hamilton, was born in Dublin, Ireland, and when young accompanied his father to America, their location being the State of Virginia, where he grew up and married Miss Rebecca Robinson, who was of English descent. They became the parents of eight children, four sons and four daughters, of whom two are living - Mrs. Holmes and her brother, Mortimer, the latter residing on the old homeplace in Indiana.

We come now to William H. Holmes, whose name heads this article. His birth has already been recorded. On the home farm he grew up and received his education in the public schools, his first teacher being Miss Lizzie Umpscher and the school-house a log structure. He was small when his father died and has always remained at home with his mother, having charge of the farm since he was old enough. The estate now comprises a fine tract of land 360 acres in extent, and under his able supervision is being successfully conducted.

September 30, 1879, Mr. Holmes was married to Miss Phoebe M. Arnold, who was born February 22, 1862, in Marion county, Iowa, daughter of Ed and Sophia (Barnhard) (sic) Arnold, pioneers of Iowa. Mr. and Mrs. Holmes have six children, namely: Edward, born April 29, 1881; Jennie, March 23, 1883; La Bernie, March 14, 1885; George A., August 21, 1890; Elma Vivian, January 7, 1892; and an infant, January 25, 1895.

Mr. Holmes has always kept himself thoroughly posted on all public issues and stands solidly on the Republican platform. His first presidential vote was cast for Grant. He is an advocate of good schools and in various ways has given his support and influence to advance the best interests of his community, and here where he has resided all his life heis an esteemed and honored citizen.


This map of four Benton Township sections lifted from an 1893 plat shows where the Holmes family and their neighbors lived. Admittedly, it's easier to understand this if you're familiar with the territory, but ... The streams indicated are the Chariton River flowing roughly east and west and Wolf Creek, flowing up from the south to join it. The New York Road cuts Sections 15 and 22 in halves. At the time this sketch was published, the William H. Holmes family lived with his mother, Mary, in the family home just at the head of the "T" intersection of the New York Road and the Wolf Creek Road leading west to what now is Highway 14. Their nearest neighbors were the George W. Redlingshafer and John J. Werts families. A new house built within the last 10 years by one of Burdette and Connie Smith's boys (sorry, but I forget which) now occupies the approximate site of the old Holmes place. Salem Cemetery, also on the New York Road, is two and three-quarters miles due north of the Holmes house

Salem Cemetery Lot No. 08: Chas. White, Owner

Lot No. 8, owned by Charles White, contains seven graves. They are those of (from south to north) Charlie White and Mary (Gookin) White, their unnamed infant daughter, Glen White, Claude C. and Cecile (White) Fuller and Charles W. Fuller. If you're interested in sorting out the complex web of relationships at Salem, Charles White is a son of William M. and Lucy White, buried on Lot. No.8; and Mary is a daughter of Samuel and Lydia Gookin, buried on Lot. No. 22.

WHITE
CHARLEY
1870-1835
MARY
1871-1964

OBITUARY: CHARLEY WHITE

The death of Charley White, well known Chariton citizen, occurred at Iowa City on Thursday forenoon, Oct. 10, 1935, at eleven o'clock, after a few weeks' illness with stomach trouble.

Deceased was born in Lucas county, Iowa, on May 20, 1870. He was the only son of William Marion and Lucy Caroline White. He was married to Mary Gookin on March 12, 1890. To this union three children were born, one dying in infancy. The two living are Mrs. Claude Fuller of Murray, Iowa, and Glen White of Chariton. There are also nine grandchildren, Charles, Harold, Kenneth, Marvin and Greta Fuller, of Murray, and Glen Jr., Bobbie, Betty and Phyllis White of Chariton. He also leaves one sister to mourn his death, Miss Alia White, of this city. His parents and one sister, Mrs. Florence Stone, preceded him in death.

He was a devoted husband and father, a splendid citizen, and his friends were numbered by his acquaintances.

Largely attended funeral services were held at the Beardsley funeral home in Chariton, Sunday afternoon at 2:00 o'clock, with the Rev. Simpson of the M.E. church of Chariton, in charge. The body was laid to rest in the Salem cemetery.

Those from out of town attending the funeral were Mr. and Mrs. Claude Fuller and family of Murray, Iowa; Mr. and Mrs. J.W. Atwell and daughter, Bonnie Marlene, of topeka, Kansas; Mr. and Mrs. Ernest Guilliams, of Winterset; Mr. and Mrs. A.R. Holmes and daughter, Doris Ann, of Des Moines; and Mr. and Mrs. Lloyd Paul, of Osceola. (undated clipping, Lucas County Genealogical Society collection)

+++

INFANT DAU.
OCT. 14, 1896

GLEN
WHITE
1891-1942

FULLER
CLAUDE C.
1891-1968
CECILE
1894-1997

CHARLES W.
FULLER
1913-1937

Salem Cemetery Lot No. 09: Wm. M. White, Owner

There appear to be only five graves on Lot No. 9, those of William M. and Lucy White; their daughter, Alia; and their son-in-law and daughter, M. Everett and Florence W. (White) Stone. Members of the family of William's and Lucy's other son, Charley, are buried on Lot No. 8. The inscriptions here are from south to north:

WHITE
WILLIAM M.
1841-1919
LUCY C.
1843-1904

OBITUARY: WILLIAM M. WHITE

William M. White, son of John and Silvia (sic) White, was born in Harrisburg, Indiana, December 20, 1841, and departed this life, August 28, 1919, at his home in Benton township at the age of 77 years, 8 months and 8 days.

He came to Iowa with his parents, June 11, 1856, and has since spent his life here. In the year of 1869, he was married to Lucy C. Gillogly, who departed this life on July 24, 1904. To this union was born three children, Chas., of Chariton; Mrs. Florence Stone, of Warren township; and Alia, of Benton township who has cared for her father during his illness.

Besides these he leaves to mourn his departure, seven grandchildren, four great grand children, two sisters, Mrs. Mary Keller, of this county, and Sarah Keller, of Wayne county, besides many relatives and friends.

Mr. White has been an invalid for a number of years but was very patient during his illness.

The funeral services were held from the Salem church, Saturday afternoon, conducted by E.A. McKim, pastor of the Christian church, of Chariton, and interment made in the Salem cemetery. (Chariton Leader, 4 September 1919)

OBITUARY: MRS. MARION WHITE

The many friends throughout the county will be pained to learn of the death of Mrs. Lucy Caroline White, wife of W.M. White, which occurred at the family home in Benton township on Sunday forenoon, July 24, 1904, at 11:25 o'clock after a lingering illness with stomach and bowel trouble. Largely attended funeral services, conducted by Rev. G. A. Hendrickson, pastor of the Christian church in this city, assisted by Rev. Carl Brown of Russell, were held at Salem church on Tuesday afternoon at two o'clock after which the remains were interred in Salem cemetery. "Blessed are the dead who die in the Lord. Yes, said the Spirit, they rest from their labors and their works do follow them."

Deceased was born in Muskingum county, Ohio, on November 6, 1843. She came to Iowa with her parents when but a child. She was married to Wm. Marion White in 1869. They were the parents of three children all of whom were at their mother's bedside when death came. She leaves an aged mother, three sisters, and two brothers, in addition to the husband and children, to mourn their loss. She was a good woman, a devoted wife and mother, a kind neighbor and friend. She had been a faithful christian and a consistent member of the Christian church at this place for many years. (The Chariton Democrat, 28 July 1904)

ALIA WHITE
1871-1963


STONE
M. EVERETT
1872-1946
FLORENCE W.
1875-1943

OBITUARY: M. EVERETT STONE
The Chariton Leader, 12 November 1946

Malcome Everett Stone, son of John and Nancy Luella Stone, was born November 26, 1872, near Chariton, Iowa, and departed this life November 4, 1946, at his home at Humeston, Iowa, at the age of 73 years, 11 months and 9 days.

On September 9, 1896, he was united in marriage to Florence White, who passed away April 13, 1934. To this union five children were born, Edmond, Thomas, Donald and Mrs. Nellie Massman, all of Chariton, and Mrs. Mable Atwell, of Lansing, Mich.

On October 24, 1943, he was married to Anna De Barthe. Early in life he united with the Christian church of Chariton, his membership continuing throughout his life. His entire life was spent in Lucas county except the last six years he has lived on his farm near Humeston. For many years he worked at the J. T. Crozier store where he made many friends. He was a member of Co. H. in Chariton when it was active several years ago.

He is survived by his widow, Anna, three sons, Edmond, Thomas, Donald, all of Chariton, two daughters, Mrs. Nellie Massman, of Chariton, and Mrs. Mable Atwell, of Lansing, Mich., twelve grandchildren and one great-grandson, two step-daughters and two step-sons, also one sister, Mrs. Eva L. Sherman, of Perry, Iowa, and one brother, Charles Stone, of Karthans, Pa.

Funeral services were held Wednesday, November 6, 1946, at the Miley Funeral Home, with the Rev. Archie Beals, of Russell, in charge. Burial service was at the Salem cemetery.

Salem Cemetery Lot No. 10: David Scott, Owner

Lot No.10, owned by David J. Scott, a son of Aaron and Elizabeth Scott (Lot No. 20), contains only one stone, a substantial gray marble monument with an urn atop it, located at the extreme south end of the lot. It contains three inscriptions, but marks the graves of only two people: Mary E., wife of David J. Scott; and their son, Merrett E., age 9. Their inscriptions are on the west and north faces of the stone, respectively. An inscription recording the death of David Scott is on the south face, telling passers-by that he his buried in the Derby Cemetery. I have been unable to find a published or official record of Merrett E. Scott's death.

North Face:
MERRETT E.
DIED
Dec. 3, 1884
AGED
9Y, 1M, 10D

A little flower of love,
That blossomed but to die,
Transplanted now above,
To bloom with God on high.
+++

West Face:
MARY E.
WIFE OF
D.J. SCOTT
DIED
Mar. 7, 1885
AGED
28y, 9M, 22D

She had no fears of death,
No sins to be forgiven;
She only closed her smiling eyes,
to hope them in heaven.
OBITUARY: MARY J. (SMITH) SCOTT

Died, in Warren (township), Lucas County, Iowa, March 7, 1885, Mary E., the beloved wife of David J. Scott.

Sister Scott was born in Ohio, May 15, 1856. While she was yet young her parents moved to Illinois and settled in Stark County. She subsequently came to Iowa, and on October 14, 1873, was united in marriage with her now bereaved companion. They resided in Salem nearly two years and then moved to Warren near Derby, where they have since lived. During a protracted meeting held last winter in the M.E. Church in Derby, Sister Scott, along with her husband, made a profession of religion and united with the church. For the past year, in the midst of much family and personal affliction, her Christian life has been very exemplary. She truly walked with God and the genuiness of her religious life was manifest in her sweet and willing resignation to the will of God. Some 3 months ago her dear little boy, Merritt, sickened and died, she being too sick at the time to follow his remains to their last resting place, but calmly assuring us she would soon follow him. (The Chariton Patriot, 18 March 1885)

Note: Lucas County Marriage records show that David Scott, 22, and Mary E. Smith, 17, were married 14 October 1873.

+++

South Face
DAVID J. SCOTT
DIED
APRIL 30, 1921
AGED
70 Yrs, 2 Ms, 18 Ds

Buried on lot 407 in Derby Cemetery
OBITUARY: DAVID J. SCOTT

The many friends throughout the county will learn with sorrow of the passing away of Mr. David J. Scott, of Derby, which occurred at his home at an early hour on Saturday morning, April 30 (1921), at the age of 70 years, 2 months and 18 days, after an extended illness with heart disease and a complication of troubles. Largely attended funeral services were held at the M.E. church in Derby on Tuesday afternoon, May 3, at 2 o'clock, and were conducted by Rev. J.W. Pressley, of Omaha, according to the special request of the departed one. Rev. Harwood, of Derby, assisted in the ceremonies and interment took place in the Derby cemetery.

David J. Scott, son of Aaron and Elizabeth Scottt, was born near Chariton on Feb. 12, 1851. He was married here on October 14, 1873 to Mary Ellen Smith, daughter of Lewis and Sarah Smith, and settled on a farm near Derby. The beloved wife was claimed by death on March 7th, 1885. To his union were born three children, Walter A., who resides at Roundup, Mont., and was unable to be present at the funeral services on Tuesday on account of illness in his family; Merrett E., who died on Dec. 3, 1884, and Mrs. H.W. Brewer, of Chariton.

He was married to Mabel Foutch, of Derby, on Nov. 25, 1885. To them two children were born, Mrs. Ens(z)er Larimer and Harry L., who reside near Derby. He also leaves one sister, Mrs. Emma McCurdy, of Bremen, Ohio; nine grand-children and numerous other relatives to mourn their loss.

"Mr. Scott united with the M.E. church in Derby under the pastorate of Rev. Lawson, and remained a strong believer in God until the day of his death. He was honest and upright in all his dealings and was esteemed by all who knew him for his many sterling traits of character. He had been in ill health for years but had been confined to his bed but a short time. His sufferings were all borne with a patience and fortitude that were remarkable. While deploring his demise, innumerable friends will extend heartfelt sympathy to the grief stricken ones who remain.

Among the number who attended the funeral service were his daughter, Mrs. H.W. Brewer and husband and children, and Mrs. T.M. Throckmorton, Mrs. Simon Scott, Mr. and Mrs. Morris Scott, Mr. Howard Scott, Mr. and Mrs. Geo. F. Carpenter, Mr. George Scott, Mr. Virgil Scott, Mrs. J.J. George, all of Chariton. (Undated clipping, Lucas County Genealogical Society collection)

Salem Cemetery Lot No. 11: W. Bryant, Owner

Seven members of the Bryant/Threlkeld family are buried on Lot No. 11 (from south to north): William W. Bryant and his wife, Laura E.; their son, Ira Bryant; their daughter, Maude (Bryant) Morrison/Hall; their son-in-law and daughter, Roy M. and Olive M. (Bryant) Threlkeld; and the Threlkelds' infant son, Lowell B.

BRYANT
W.W. BRYANT
1852-1908
LAURA B.
1882-1923

DEATH OF WESLEY BRYANT
The Chariton Herald, 20 August 1908

Mr. Wm. Wesley Bryant, a well known and highly respected resident of Benton township, died at his home last Thursday, August 13, 1908, after an extended illness with dropsy and other complaints. Funeral services were held at Salem church on Saturday morning at ten o'clock, conducted by Rev. Shenton, of Russell, after which interment took place in the Salem cemetery.

Deceased was born in Indiana on Dec. 30, 1853 (sic). He had been a resident of this county for many years and had won the regard of all with whom he came in contact by his many sterling qualities. He is survived by his wife, three daughters and one son, who will have the sympathy of the community in their great grief.

BRYANT
IRA BRYANT
Feb. 7, 1883-Jan. 14, 1905

MAUDE HALL
1883-1935

DEATH NOTICE: MAUDE (BRYANT) HALL
Chariton Herald-Patriot, 7 February 1935

Mrs. F. W. Hall, 50, died at her home in Arvada, Colo., on Monday, Feb. 4. The body was brought to Chariton yesterday and taken to Downs-Miley Funeral Home, and this afternoon at two o'clock, funeral services were held at the Salem church in Benton township, conducted by Rev. A. E. Beals, of Russell, and burial took place in the Salem cemetery.

Mrs. Hall, who grew to young womanhood in this vicinity, was formerly Miss Maud (sic) Bryant. She is survived by her husband and by two sisters and one brother, Mrs. Roy Threlkeld, of near Chariton, Mrs. Elmer Curtis and Floyd Bryant, of Des Moines.

OBITUARY: MRS. FRED W. HALL
The Chariton Leader, 12 February 1935

Mrs. Fred W. Hall, formerly of Lucas county, died at her home in Arvada, Colo., on Feb. 4, 1935, at the age of 51 years, 10 months and 11 days. The body was brought to Chariton on Wednesday and taken to the Downs-Miley Funeral home and on Thursday afternoon at two o'clock, funeral services were held at the Salem church in Benton township, conducted by Rev. A. E. Beals, and burial took place in the Salem cemetery.

Maude Irene Bryant, eldest child of William Wesley and Laura E. Bryant, was born at Griswold, Ia., on March 23, 1883. At the age of twelve years she moved with her parents to Lucas county, locating on a farm southeast of Chariton, where she grew to womanhood.

On February 14, 1909, she was married to George Morrison. After a year's residence on a farm near this city they went west, and her home had since been in Wyoming and Colorado. On April 19, 1930, she was married to Fred Hall, who survives her. She also leaves two sisters and one brother, Mrs. Ollie Threlkeld, of near Chariton, Mrs. Edna Curtis and Floyd Bryant, both of Des Moines.

THRELKELD
ROY M.
1883-1970
OLIVE M.
1886-1956

LOWELL B.
INFANT SON OF
ROY & OLLIE
THRELKELD

Salem Cemetery Lot No. 12: Pettinger/Bryant/Wray

Salem Cemetery Lot No. 12 apparently was purchased by Joab. C. Wray when his mother, Charlotte, died on 5 March 1891. He died less that a year later and was buried beside her. They were joined in 1897 by an infant niece and granddaughter. These three graves are located at the south end of the lot. Many years later, the north portion of the lot was acquired by Floyd and Katheryn (Pettinger) Bryant. Finally, Robert and Erville (Threlkeld) Pettinger were buried there. Robert was Katheryn's younger brother. These transcriptions are from north to south:

PETTINGER
(west face)
ERVILLE M.
May 21, 1918
Feb. 3, 2004
ROGERT G.
Nov. 2, 1910
Mar. 20, 2000
Married Mar. 10, 1940



PETTINGER
(east face)
OUR CHILDREN:
MARILYN, GERALD
THOMAS, NICK

OBITUARY: ERVILLE MAXINE PETTINGER

Erville Maxine Pettinger died Feb. 3, 2004, at Quiburi Mission Samaritan Center in Benson, Ariz. She was 85. She was born May 21, 1918, at home in rural Russell, Iowa, to Roy McKinley Threlkeld and Olive Bryant Threlkeld. She graduated from Russell High School in 1935, then attended junior college in Chariton, Iowa, for a secretarial course. She married Robert Pettinger March 10, 1940, at the home of the Reverend A. E. Beals.

Erville and Robert lived briefly in Oregon, but returned to Chariton after the birth of their first child. In 1945, Robert and Erville took over her family farm southeast of Chariton and lived there the rest of their lives. In recent years, they spent winters in Benson, Ariz.

Erville was a dedicated farm wife and mother. She cultivated a large garden, dressed and sold chickens, canned produce and baked bread. She and Robert pressed many gallons of apple cider from their numerous apple trees. Whether working in her flower beds, gathering hickory nuts along the Chariton River, or going on walks with her grandchildren, Erville loved being outdoors. She also liked to paint and sculpt, and enjoyed camping at the Iowa State Fair.

Erville was a member of the Friendly Neighborhood Club and the Lucas County Farm Bureau Women. She was a 4-H leader for many years, and was very active in Salem Community Church until its closure, then Bethel United Methodist Church. Erville loved visiting with people. She traveled with the Friendship Force to South America and Europe, and over the years, Robert and Erville hosted visitors from many places including Japan, Ireland, Australia and Germany.

She was preceded in death by her husband of 60 years, her parents and an infant brother, Lowell Burton.

Erville is survived by her children and their spouses: Marilyn and Dean Hall of Lake View, Iowa; Gerald Pettinger of Russell, Iowa; Dr. Thomas and Susan Pettinger of Benson, Ariz.; Dr. Nicholas and Suzanne Pettinger of Fort Wayne, Inc.; 10 grandchildren; 8 great-grandchildren; seven great-great-grandchildren and many friends.

Her body was cremated and the cremains will be buried during a memorial service Saturday, May 29, 2004, at 10:30 a.m. at Salem Cemetery in rural Chariton. Lunch will be served following the memorial service. Family and friends are invited to attend. (Undated clipping, Lucas County Genealogical Society collection)

OBITUARY: ROBERT PETTINGER

Robert Gerald Pettinger was born Nov. 2, 1910, in Adair, Iowa, to John Baptiste and Marguerite Shaffer Pettinger. He passed away Monday, March 20, 2000, at Eldorado Hospital in Tucson, Ariz., at the age of 89. The body was cremated, and a memorial service and burial of cremains will be held at a later date at Salem Cemetery in rural Chariton.

Robert graduated from Lucas High School in 1929. He worked as a lumberjack in Oregon and on a gold dredge in Alaska and attended diesel mechanic school in Portland.

On March 10, 1940, he was married to Erville Threlkeld by the Rev. A.E. Beals at the Russell parsonage. Robert worked at Johnson Machine Works in Chariton aiding in the war effort.

In 1945, Robert and Erville moved to her family farm southeast of Chariton, where they raised their family and farmed for many years. He designed and built the family home in 1951. Robert retired from farming in 1985, but he and Erville continued to live on the home place, enjoying their garden, ponds, wildlife, and making cider from their many apple trees.

Robert's hobbies included hunting, fishing, trapping and woodworking. He could fix anything and spent many hours helping his family with their projects. His greatest joy was his grandchildren. In recent years, Robert and Erville spent winters in Benson, Ariz.

Robert is survived by his wife of 60 years, Erville; a daughter, Marilyn Hall and her husband Dean of Lake View, Iowa; three sons, Gerald of Russell, Dr. Thomas Pettinger and his wife Sue of Benson, Ariz., and Dr. Nicholas Pettinger and his wife Suzanne of Rolla, Mo.; ten grandchildren, Bob Hall, Jim Hall and Lori Hall Auen; Sarah, Anne and Susie Pettinger; Lindsay, Nichole and Eric Pettinger; and Gabe Pettinger; eight great-grandchildren; six great-great-grandsons; a brother, Lloyd Pettinger and wife Ruth of Harbor, Ore.; and sister, Athyl Hunerdosse of Des Moines; and many nieces and nephews.

He was preceded in death by his parents; two sisters, Katheryn Bryant and Irene Zimmerline; and three brothers, Earl Pettinger, Chris Pettinger and John Pettinger.

Memorial contributions may be made to Bethel United Methodist Church or the American Cancer Society. (Undated clipping, Lucas County Genealogical Society collection)

+++


BRYANT
KATHERYN M.
1900-1999
FLOYD M.
1903-1960

BLOOD CLOT FATAL TO FLOYD BRYANT

Funeral services were held at noon Tuesday for Floyd M. Bryant, 56, of Des Moines. Services were conducted from the Hamilton Funeral Home in Des Moines.

Mr. Bryant, former Chariton resident, died Saturday from a blood clot following surgery. He had been ill for about two weeks.

He had been a resident of Des Moines for the past 27 years and was employed as a warehouseman for Firestone Tire Co. He was a member of the Masonic Lodge and the Methodist Church in Chariton but attended the Union Park Methodist Church in Des Moines.

He is survived by his wife, Katheryn, of Des Moines; two daughters, Mrs. Marion Thomas and Mrs. Boneta Brown, both of Des Moines; one sister, Mrs. Edna Curtis of Van Nuys, Calif., and two grandchildren.

Interment was in Salem cemetery with Masonic graveside rites performed at 2 p.m. Tuesday. (The Chariton Herald Patriot, 4 February 1960).

+++


JESSIE
Infant Daughter Of
A.A. & R.A.
MARTIN
Mar. 4, 1897



WRAY

CHARLOTTE
Wife
OF
Andrew Wray
DIED
Mar. 5, 1891
AGED
68 Ys, 6 Ms.
2 Ds.

JOAB C.
WRAY
DIED
Jan. 16, 1892
AGED
49 Ys, 5 Ms
5 Ds

DEATH NOTICE: CHARLOTTE WRAY

DIED: At her home in Lincoln Tp. on Thursday, March 5, 1891, Mrs. Charlotte Wray, aged about 69 years. She had been sick about a week. The funeral services were conducted at her home on Saturday by Staten Hughes of Lucas and the remains interred in the Ragtown (sic, should be Salem) cemetery. She has been a resident of Lucas Co. for many years and enjoyed the friendship of a wide circle of acquaintances. (The Chariton Herald, 19 March 1891; no obituary found)

DEATH NOTICE: JOAB C. WRAY

WRAY: At his home in this city (Chariton) Saturday evening, Jan. 16, 1892, at 6 o'clock, Mr. Joab C. Wray, aged about 50 years. Mr. Wray was a bachelor and has lived in Lucas County for a number of years. He leaves three sisters and a brother to mourn his departure. The funeral was conducted Monday at 1 o'clock and the remains interred in the Chariton (should be Salem) Cemetery. (The Chariton Herald, 21 January 1892)

OBITUARY NO. 1: JOAB C. WRAY

Died, at his home in Chariton, Jan. 16, 1892, Joab C. Wray, in the 50th year of his age.

Mr. Wray was born in Bartholomew Co., Ind., Aug. 11, 1848 (should be 1842). With his parents he moved to Benton township, Lucas Co., Iowa, where his father died in July 1861. With difficulty he managed to provide for his widowed mother and her five children left largely in his care. By industry, economy and good management he converted the prairie land into a fertile farm and a good home. In 1884 he became dangerously ill with the fatal disease consumption. His aged mother watched him for many months waiting for the sad end. But alas! she was taken suddenly ill and died March 5th, 1891. All his brothers and sisters were married except his sister Ruth Wray, who now took the place of his mother in his declining years. As he owned a house and lot in Chariton he moved to this town Dec. 3, 1891. All that medical science and kind friends could do only prolonged his life a little longer. After over seven years of patient suffering he died Jan. 16, 1892. (The Chariton Democrat, 28 January 1892)

OBITUARY NO. 2: JOAB C. WRAY

Note: The obituary which follows is very similar to the Democrat obituary, but appears to be more complete and more accurate.

DIED - At his home in Chariton, Iowa, Jan. 16, 1892, Joab C. Wray, in the 50th year of his age.

"Mr. Wray was born in Bartholomew county, Indiana, August 11, 1842. With his parents he moved to Benton township, Lucas county, Iowa, in 1859, where they lived for two years. In March, 1861, they moved to their land in Lincoln township, Lucas county, where his father died in July, 1861. With difficulty he managed to provide for his widowed mother and her five children left largely in his care. By industry, economy and good management he converted the prairie land into a fertile farm and a good home. In 1884 he became dangerously ill with that fatal disease consumption. His aged mother watched him for many months, waiting for the sad end, but, alas! she was taken suddenly ill, and died March 5, 1891. All his brothers and sisters were married except his sister Ruth Wray, who now took the place of his mother in his declining days. As he owned a house and lot in Chariton, he moved to this town December 3, 1891. All that medical science and kind friends could do only prolonged life a little longer. After over seven years' suffering patiently, he died on January 16, 1892. "D.T.O." (The Chariton Herald, 28 January 1892)